Comments with -10 or lower "thumbs" are removed from display.

• 
  -3 thumbs!

  ulmelinejoodik | June 14, 2008
  Goldeneye as number one? That's a joke. I know everyone loved it when it was out but I'm *bleep*ing sorry, it has not stood the test of time and a list of the best FPS' of all time should be ones that have stayed the best. Also, Halo as number 2? Absolutely not. Halo 3 is the best Halo to date, no question about it. It is better than the other Halo's by leaps and bounds. This is a highly flawed list. Terrible really.
  • 
    -2 thumbs!

    weskraudaon | June 15, 2008
    Well actually, Halo sucked balls. Halo 2 was the best in the series.
  • 
    -2 thumbs!

    Final Blade | June 15, 2008
    <sub>You guys know shit about Halo. Halo 1 at its time of release was leaps and bound better and did things no other FPS did so far. Same as Half Life 2. Hell HL2 should be number 1.
    
    Sorry but Halo 2 or 3 wasn't anywhere near the greatness of Halo 1.</sub>
    • 
      -1 thumbs!

      Storm | June 15, 2008
      Although I'm not a fan of Halo, I must say, Halo 2 was the best of the trilogy. And HL > HL2 by a margin, imo.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Gothic Girl | June 14, 2008
  Ah, Goldeneye ... I spent many a day (*cough*weeks*cough*) having fun with that multiplayer mode.
  • 
    -1 thumbs!

    LZ Schneider | June 14, 2008
    Me too, I used to LOVE that game's multiplayer @_@
    • 
      -1 thumbs!

      Xenctuary | June 14, 2008
      Just as long as the "No Oddjobs" rule was in effect!
      
      
• 
  0 thumbs!

  BANDITO ATTACK | June 14, 2008
  *bleep* goldeneye
  
  trying to play a fps without 2 joysticks, or a mouse+keyboard simply doesn't work. especially with that idiotic n64 controller.
  • 
    -1 thumbs!

    black doom | June 14, 2008
    Nintendo-sixty-four-ever. I loved that console so much, still do.
• 
  -3 thumbs!

  Taker4ever | June 14, 2008
  Goldeneye is weak now. Amazing for it's time, but it has not stood the test of time like other FPS games. I still play the first (and best) Halo on PC - awesome game.
• 
  -3 thumbs!

  Remino52 | June 14, 2008
  No Metroid Prime?That is a piece of crap.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Jaw Knee | June 14, 2008
  Metroid is actually considered a First Person Adventure game. But yeah, Golden Eye? I love the game, but it shouldn't be at number one.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Nath | June 14, 2008
  Yeah, Goldeneye was good as an N64 game, just as Halo is good for an Xbox game.
  
  Doom 3?
  
  And there's no Deus Ex, which is just as much an FPS as Bioshock is.
  
  Also, as much as I love Wolfenstein 3D, it's obviously inferior to most modern products.
• 
  3 thumbs!

  Donnelly | June 14, 2008
  Half Life 2 at number 8?
  
  Silly sods.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Shadow net583x s | June 14, 2008
  I agree with this for the most part. I haven't played Goldeneye since I was really young, so I doubt I could understand how revolutionary it was.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Redemption | June 14, 2008
  Well from an old school gamer's perspective - and mind you I haven't played all the titles, I feel that Half Life 1 was a superior overall experience than HL2, just because it was so innovative.
  
  I also feel that leaving out Unreal 1 is a huge mistake, it pretty much pioneered several aspects of FPS including complicated scripted events triggered by players, an excellent player co-op capability, HUGE outdoor areas with a sky that looks literally like a sky with parallax on clouds, and hugely variant levels.
  
  Quake 1 is a definite win but Doom3? Doom 1 and Doom 2 were more innovative for their time.
  
  (I'm taking this from the single player perspective. For multiplayer I'd have to vote for Quake 2, Q3A, and CounterStrike).
  • 
    -1 thumbs!

    chautemoc | June 15, 2008
    Especially considering Doom 3 was a "reimagining" of Doom 1..
    
    Perfect Dark, Turok 2, Bioshock, Doom and Half Life would make up my top 5 I think (in no order, though PD and Bioshock would be tied for first)..top ten would be filled by Quake, Doom 3, and..not sure what else.
• 
  1 thumbs!

  Armed Rebel | June 14, 2008
  Needs Perfect Dark, Half Life 1.
  
  I'd put Perfect Dark at #1 (I had so much fun with that game), Goldeneye at #2, then Half Life, then Counterstrike then Half Life 2. Whatever after that.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  black doom | June 14, 2008
  I haven't checked the list yet but I say Doom and Goldeneye. Now to check.
  
  Cool, wish I had gone with my gut and guessed Halo as well.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  gonzab | June 14, 2008
  LOL people, what you need is a top 50, cuz all those games you want streched in a top10 don't simply fit in there.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  SvR2008 | June 14, 2008
  The list sounds about right, Resistance should be their though
  • 
    -1 thumbs!

    Lost_Cause | June 14, 2008
    Resistance is better than any of those 10, as well as others not listed (such as Half Life 1)?
    
    Yeah... no.
  • 
    2 thumbs!

    Donnelly | June 15, 2008
    LOLOLOL
    
    Resistance amongst the top 10 FPS's of all time?
    
    Wtf have you been smoking?
• 
  3 thumbs!

  Seeker X | June 14, 2008
  So Goldeneye's there but not its successor Perfect Dark which bested Goldeneye in EVERYTHING?
• 
  2 thumbs!

  Aussie Legend | June 15, 2008
  The original Perfect Dark also deserved a spot on there some, it was a game ahead of its time.
  • 
    -1 thumbs!

    chautemoc | June 15, 2008
    I've still yet to see anything recreate its excellence. Most haven't even come close, including PD Zero. Just my opinion of course..but yeah, I have a deep-seeded passion for PD.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  weskraudaon | June 15, 2008
  Resistance? I know that it was underrated but still, you can't say it was one of the best. And Goldeneye is not #1. Number 10 at best.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Matty1357 | June 15, 2008
  Goldeneye.
  xDD
  It was good, but not #1 good.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  weskraudaon | June 15, 2008
  I thought this was about the best, not the most innovative FPS games ever.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Subzer0 | June 15, 2008
  Ah... Counter Strike. Brings back memories. Defintely deserved a mention.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Arcaida | June 15, 2008
  I would much rather play Golden Eye than any newer FPS games with the exception of Call of Duty.
• 
  -2 thumbs!

  Jace_C88 | June 15, 2008
  Good news Goldeneye fans: Goldeneye lives on.
  Download the Goldeneye: Source mod for the PC to relive the game in a multiplayer PC remake! All it needs is a few more players so get onto it!
  www.goldeneyesource.com
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Tromonator133 | June 15, 2008
  It seems like Goldeneye has gotten old. I would think that Bioshock wouldn't be 10.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Rinkydink | June 15, 2008
  Ah Goldeneye, what a legendary game that is. I feel that Perfect Dark should be on there since I liked that better than Goldeneye overall, but being there at that moment when Goldeneye first came to the N64 was just fantastic.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Storm | June 15, 2008
  Goldeneye for #1, eh? I can't complain. They should have just added '(Series)' to some of these titles. CoD and CoD2 were kick-ass, yet only CoD4 is listed. Half-Life is amazing, yet only Half-Life 2 is listed...and...the first Doom is my favorite of the 'trilogy,' not listed.
  
  Still, decent list, brings back memories.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  SvR2008 | June 16, 2008
  How can you say Resistance shouldn't be their! It definitely should be in the top 10.
  • 
    0 thumbs!

    Donnelly | June 16, 2008
    Resistance was alright, but nowhere near as good as any of the games mentioned there.
    
    Is it as good as Half Life? Is it as good as Call of Duty 2? Is it as good as Perfect Dark? Is it as good as Bioshock (the game that would be knocked off the list)?
    
    No. No it isn't.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  pwned227 | June 21, 2008
  I would have put HL2 lower on the list like around number 3.
  • 
    0 thumbs!

    Donnelly | June 21, 2008
    I would've put it at number 1 if I could.
    
    In fact, I would put it higher if I could.