123

Mii "plagiarism" rains on Check Mii Out parade

Wolfwood | November 15, 2007 | Other | Wii 
Nintendo's latest Wii Channel, Check Mii Out, greatly facilitates the sharing of personalized Mii avatars. However, GameCritics opines that the channel was way too late for the party to allow creative talent to make a geniune foothold. Since the launch of the Wii, the relative inconvenience in sharing Miis before Check Mii Out's debut meant it was simply easier for users to post tutorials detailing the creation process of their Miis.

These tutorials themselves are meant to be useful guides for personal use, but GameCritics laments the number of contributors on Check Mii Out who have used them to basically copy other Miis to post as their own. We can imagine that not all such contributions are truly malicious in intent; if a user has a Mii he/she likes regardless of how they made it, they may not feel it is wrong to post it for the purpose of sharing. On the other hand, it is also not unreasonable for the original creators to ask for proper credit. Unfortunately, as with other types of game contributions here or elsewhere, this is not always easy to establish.
Looking over the submissions of several of these “artisans” revealed that a large proportion of their Miis were exact or nearly-exact copies of designs created by other artists, mostly from MiiPlaza.net. It’s too bad that these copycats don’t seem to have any problem stealing other people's work and shamelessly passing it off as their own. What’s lacking here is a firm sense of Mii ethics.

The sad thing is that this could have all been avoided if Nintendo had provided some of the services contained in the Check Mii Out Channel from the beginning. The old system for sending and receiving Miis preserved the identity of the original creator in that any Miis received from another user are tagged with that user’s name and are un-editable. But since Nintendo made it so absurdly difficult to send Miis, this feature turned out to be of little use. Players found it easier to just copy the Miis from pictures and tutorials.

Now that it's here, the Check Mii Out Channel provides a relatively easy way for Wii owners to distribute Miis. It's just too bad it's showing up so late.

News Story attached to:
2 comments | go to source (www.gamecritics.com) | Add to favorites! favourite this article | send to friend
Register as a member to subscribe comments.

Comments with -10 or lower "thumbs" are removed from display.

  • 4 thumbs!
    TwilightPrince | November 15, 2007
    I think you guys are taking the Mii's a little too seriously. It's not like people are making money by copying someone else's Miis and passing it off as their own. The Mii Contest Channel is all about having fun and looking at some of your favorite characters/TV stars recreated as Miis.

    I think all pride goes out the window here. Asking for people to give you credit everytime they want to create a Darth Vadar mii or Chuck Norris Mii is ridiculous.
    • 0 thumbs!
      Catboy14 | November 16, 2007
      Plus, if they don't want it copied, then they shouldn't have posted it in the first place.

This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.

Submit Newshelp

Top Contributors

This Month
Akira_EX 1331 pts
chautemoc 1184 pts
Gothic Girl 1033 pts
Tyranitar24 1023 pts
Deathsythe 620 pts
Cruxis Mana 541 pts
tidus04 513 pts
Krunal 493 pts
Silver Mir.. 464 pts
Livewire_19 426 pts
All-Time
Gothic Girl 17726 pts
Krunal 12131 pts
Linkin Par.. 9906 pts
Final Blade 9012 pts
chautemoc 8989 pts
Silver Mir.. 8496 pts
xsynergyx 7909 pts
mistermostyn 7668 pts
Akira_EX 7388 pts
Tyranitar24 6260 pts

Stats

Today
Published News: 16
Comments: 147
Points Given: 324
Users Registered: 0
This Month
Published News: 448
Comments: 3368
Points Given: 7432
Users Registered: 38
All Time
Published News: 10796
Comments: 73915
Points Given: 174642
Users Registered: 558

Conventions / Trade Shows

(0.1354/d/aeon)