172

"Violent video games should be banned. But violent literature is ok"

Gothic Girl | April 05, 2008 | News | Misc 
Surprise, surprise. Yet another anti-violent video game activist is out and about, and claiming that gamers are all a bunch of soon-to-be murderers. In this case, it's Phyllis Schlafley, who believes that violent video games should not be protected under the First Ammendment ... but violent literature is ok.

Judges around America have allowed violent video games to be sold (with the appropriate rating of course) because they have a right to be protected under the First Amendment. Such court cases often have psychologists revealing their research on violent video games - That they do not affect people negatively.

Phyllis Schlafley does not agree though. In fact she believes that "supremacist judges" are wrong in allowing these games to be sold, and she says why.

There is a point that Schlafley is clearly missing in her article though: Violent video games aren't allowed to be sold to children. They have clear teen and adult ratings for a reason.

GamesRadar also brought up a good point in this article, which could be directly applied to Schlafley's ignorance ...

quote GamesRadar
When it comes to games though we forget that people have brains, and censor or even ban them “just to be on the safe side” in case someone forgets they’re playing a videogame and goes on a killing spree.
Hey, guess what? I know this stuff isn’t real! I’m controlling it all by pressing buttons! And when I stop pressing those buttons, the stuff stops happening! It’s a bit of a clue.
Extremely violent video games have become the dangerous obsession of a significant portion of our youth, and several towns and states have passed ordinances intended to prevent minors from buying or viewing them. But judicial supremacists are striking down these laws by claiming this extremely graphic violence deserves the same First Amendment protection as Shakespeare.

That decision acknowledged a psychologist's expert testimony that violent video games frequently lead to aggressive behavior, yet inexplicably rejected it, noting instead that a high school principal who testified was unable to prove that violent video games cause psychological harm to teens who play them.

The decision compared violent video games to classic works of literature such as "The Odyssey," "The Divine Comedy" and "War and Peace."

These decisions ignore the way violent video games encourage role-playing, making the child the perpetrator of violence in a manner that no book or movie can. It does not require a leap in imagination to see the risk of immature players transferring violent role-playing to real life.

A teenager who learns how to murder and mutilate human beings in video games is desensitized to commit heinous crimes against his neighbors. Nothing in the First Amendment should prevent regulations to stop this, supremacist judges to the contrary notwithstanding.
12 comments | go to source (worldnetdaily.com) | send to friend | add alt source
Register as a member to subscribe comments.

Comments with -5 or lower "thumbs" are removed from display.

  • 0 thumbs!
    Play ISDF | April 05, 2008
    Let me just go grab my Mobile suit, charge up my Plasmids, pick up my Normandy from the dry dock and get my Demon Hunter friend while I'm at it so I can go on a murderous spree and start stabbing and blasting everything I see. I'm sure it'll be loads of fun!

    Can we lock up stupid people like this already PLEASE!?.
  • 1 thumbs!
    TurMoiL911 | April 05, 2008
    Anyone else picking up large traces of hypocrisy and bias coming from this old lady ?

    Violent video games don't influence kids to commit crimes any more than violent movies do. If a parent doesn't want their kid to play violent games, don't *bleep*ing buy them it. Most stores these days that sell video games have policies that state they will not sell M-rated video games to anyone who is not 17 years old or older.
  • 2 thumbs!
    Linkin Park Fan | April 05, 2008
    The only time I will go on a violant killing spree is when zombies or demons attack. And When that day comes, I'll be thankfull that all these video games prepared me.
  • 0 thumbs!
    reaver11 | April 05, 2008
    There are some things certain people must let be. This is one of those persons, and this is one of those things. Leave it alone you old bag. Go and get a rally against the war or something. Something thats actually gonna have a positive outcome.
  • 1 thumbs!
    Seeker X | April 05, 2008
    quote
    Interactive Digital Software Association v. St. Louis County likewise held that violent video games are free speech because they contain "stories, imagery, age-old themes of literature and messages, even an ideology, just as books and movies do." But so do some adult pornographic movies, and no one insists there is a First Amendment right to sell them to children.
    Enough said. By now I think it's safe to say that the First Amendment CAN be considered as freedom of media...in which video games are a sort of media anyways.
  • 2 thumbs!
    tidus04 | April 05, 2008
    What a whore, she doesn't even know what she is talking about.

    quote
    Violent video games aren't allowed to be sold to children.
    They are not! I go into a shop. Aim to buy an a 18+ game and they ask me for ID. ID bitch!. How can I get past that I will never know.. I will though give you some advice. Go hunting those responsible +18 year olds parents who are giving games to the kids as they should be getting the blame if anything comes of it, not the games itself.
  • 0 thumbs!
    Gamer of the Year | April 05, 2008
    Well guys, looks like we have another Jack Tompson follower on our hands. GET SCHLAFLY!!!!!!!11!!!!! >=D
  • 0 thumbs!
    HilaryDuffGta | April 05, 2008
    *turns up Hilary duff cd and proceeds to blast away 45 peds in saints row*


    God this broad is a moron and what she said on game politics was pretty damn funny..."resident evil 4 is such a violent game it shouldnt even be sold to adults" Go to hell and dont think you have the right to tell grown adults what they can and cant play...When will this anti game crap go away..
  • 0 thumbs!
    Trend | April 05, 2008
    Wow, talk about hypocritical. I mean, if she does a lot of violent writing, kids can get ideas from that, just the same from video games. Either she stops writing violent things, and goes against them too, or shes a hypocrit.
  • 0 thumbs!
    Goyun SSJ15 | April 06, 2008
    You can tell from her ancient-looking picture that she probably doesnt even know what a video-game IS.

    Violence has been a part of society forever. You may as well just ban all violence, from movies too, oh wait, except books remember!

    Rediculous. Normal people an handle violence if they hoose to expose themsleves to it. It's only mentally-unstable people that react to it and copy it.
  • 0 thumbs!
    Carlyon | April 07, 2008
    Like others have said, she has definitely never played a video game before. I mean, yeah, some game are violent. But all are a bit of fun!

    Banning games consoles will have a massive effect on the economy too, I'll have you know.
  • 0 thumbs!
    theundertakergonzo | April 07, 2008
    I find it bizarre how someone to go to say this, i mean i find it really stupid how one person can go and have a major rant about something like this when violent video games are played every day and no one else seems to complain. She should realise that violent games appeal to some yet not others. Especially how she can say that if you learn how to murder and mutilate people through games, that makes me laugh to say the least.

This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.

Submit Newshelp

Recent Forum Threads

Top Contributors

This Month
Gothic Girl 339 pts
chautemoc 262 pts
Deathsythe 213 pts
Silver Mir.. 148 pts
Tyranitar24 115 pts
Akira_EX 112 pts
Coltrain 74 pts
bbb7002004 69 pts
Agrias 50 pts
All-Time
Gothic Girl 14598 pts
Krunal 11813 pts
Linkin Par.. 9920 pts
Final Blade 8638 pts
xsynergyx 8079 pts
mistermostyn 7868 pts
Silver Mir.. 7334 pts
chautemoc 6714 pts
ITANI 6350 pts
Storm 5633 pts

Stats

Today
Published News: 29
Comments: 148
Points Given: 391
Users Registered: 0
This Month
Published News: 109
Comments: 757
Points Given: 1701
Users Registered: 5
All Time
Published News: 9788
Comments: 65131
Points Given: 156550
Users Registered: 480

Conventions / Trade Shows

(0.2940/d/aeon)