Comments with -10 or lower "thumbs" are removed from display.

• 
  0 thumbs!

  black doom | January 23, 2008
  I don't buy it.
  
  For one thing isn't Ashly meant to appear in the background of the Wario Ware stage. Furthermore all the images I can make out are of poses we already had. Lastly the graphical styles are blended rather poorly.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Play ISDF | January 23, 2008
  I'm not sure if I buy it or not, especially since I can't tell who the hell some of those people are due to the puny writing or bad pics. If it's real though, people are gonna be happy with the inclusion of some unconfirmed people in there.
• 
  1 thumbs!

  Avalith | January 23, 2008
  Do I see Marth?
  
  Oh man, if this is true, I'm definitely going to have to get Brawl.
  • 
    0 thumbs!

    Storm | January 23, 2008
    Highly unlikely that it's true, but ditto...I hope he's in. =D
• 
  1 thumbs!

  Oogity_Boogity_Boo | January 23, 2008
  I doubt it. I'd be fine if this is the roster, but many of the images are in different styles, like black doom said. This would be a good lineup, but I don't buy it.
• 
  1 thumbs!

  Akira_EX | January 23, 2008
  I'm pretty sure this is fake.
• 
  2 thumbs!

  Sonic Flash | January 23, 2008
  It does suggest a number of "model swap" characters that I recall them downplaying in this one. I noticed Black Shadow there, and can't imagine how he would differ so greatly from Ganondorf and Captain Falcon and the other heavy characters to warrant being there.
  
  Characters I can't quite make out:
  [2,4] - Ridley? Some Metroid thing?
  [2,6] - Sylux or some other dumb MP:H character? Dark Samus?
  [3,1] - Fox's wolf enemy or whatever?
  [3,10/11] - Some FE girl + Marth?
  [4,9] - ?
  
  I would hope that all of these characters would have unique move sets and warrant being in the game. A lot of them seem like they could be model swaps or alternate colors.
  • 
    1 thumbs!

    Akira_EX | January 23, 2008
    [2,4] - Ridley
    [2,6] - Dark Samus
    [3,1] - Wolf O'Donnell - Fox's rival
    [3,10] - Micaiah (Radiant Dawn)
    [3,11] - Marth
    [4,9] - I think it's Masked Man from Mother 3.
    
    But then again, I'm pretty sure this picture was proven fake already.
• 
  1 thumbs!

  Jesse1234567 | January 23, 2008
  Just a few problems with that roster:
  
  1) Micaiah's picture it her 2D Radiant Dawn picture rather than having updated graphics like Ike (though I'm sure she is still in there).
  2) Sakurai wanted 3 third party characters, Snake and Sonic are the only ones there.
  3) It's doubtful for a cell shaded character like Link to be in there.
  
  Of all the characters on there, I'm sure the only ones who really will be in the game who aren't confirmed yet are:
  -Ashley
  -Krystal
  -Bowser Jr.
  -Black Shadow
  -Micaiah
  -Lucario
  -Ness
  -Mr. Game & Watch
  -Midna
  -Ganondorf
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Jesse1234567 | January 23, 2008
  Also just noticed this now, but Donkey Kong and Diddy Kong only have "Donkey" and "Diddy" over there picture, their full names aren't there like they should be.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  gotenks992 | January 23, 2008
  Still have my doubts that this is the final roster. Not to mention I don't agree with it. But I guess we'll know officially on the 31st.
• 
  1 thumbs!

  Gregory2590 | January 23, 2008
  Look at K-rool and luigi.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Jaw Knee | January 23, 2008
  Look super real, but at the same time, I dunno why they'd put Midna as a playable character. And that box art is obviously fake.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Capn Droid | January 23, 2008
  Everything is fake, pretty much. Wind Waker Link and previously posted pictures equal fail.
  
  Nice Photoshop, I admit.
• 
  1 thumbs!

  neto_360 | January 24, 2008
  Most likely a fake. I can't even tell who some of the characters are in the pictures anyways XD
  
  I can wait for Brawl to see who is on the final roster. Or for Nintendo to announce it themselves.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Benk_92 | January 24, 2008
  If this is real I will sign everyone's guestbook who posts in here.
  
  Isn't gonna happen.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Yoshi Freak | January 24, 2008
  Some, But a Very Few Look Real, But Most look Fake.
  
  The Ness Was a good Fake... The Rest are 2D Artwork Mostly.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  chaosmonkix | January 24, 2008
  what happened to zero suit samus?
  • 
    0 thumbs!

    Jesse1234567 | January 24, 2008
    Zero Suit Samus can only be used when you use Samus' Final Smash, so she won't appear in the roster. Same goes for Sheik, since you can only use her through Zelda's Down Special Move. Most likely if you hold A again when starting a battle, you will be Sheik and Zero Suit Samus rather than Zelda and Samus like how it worked for Zelda and Sheik in Melee.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Murray3 | January 24, 2008
  how any one could fall for this I don't know...
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Sonic Flash | January 24, 2008
  You have to admit though that if they were going to include a Young Link, they'd use WW Link.
  
  ...And that if they did use WW Link, that they'd bother to use the cel shading technique. Therefore I wouldn't call Young Link fake based entirely on the art style.
  
  Micaiah looks drawn though, which makes me skeptical. Probably a fake overall.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Bri | January 24, 2008
  LUIGI!
  
  But since everyone is ripping this to shreds, it does look semi-fake, especially cel-shaded Young Link. Who knows, we may be wrong. Still, Luigi had better be in.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  The Primagen | January 25, 2008
  Midna? Dark Samus? King K.Rool? kay..
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Remino52 | January 25, 2008
  This is incredible.....But it is not that believable.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Oceanic Sun | January 25, 2008
  According to serebii.net, a Pokemon website, Lucario and Jigglypuff are both confirmed. By looking at these rosters, I do believe they may also be right.
  
  I can see Ganondorf, Midna, and what appears to be The Four Swords Link.